DCSIMG
What is the best BI tool - a new survey was released - ItayBraun

ItayBraun

What is the best BI tool - a new survey was released

 

At Linked In, every now and then there is a discussion about the best BI tool.

The discussion looks like this:

John - Oracle OBIEE is the best tool in the market

Jeff - Actually, I work with Microstrategy and I think this is the best tool

John - well, I use Microsoft BI and I find it absolutely fantastic.

And so it goes on and on, endless pointless statements. To answer such a big question you need a good research. Therefore, I was very happy to read about the new BI Tool Survey (http://www.bi-survey.com/  )  written by BARC (Business Application Research Center).

The BI Survey 9 uncovers the truth about why real-world organizations select BI products, how they use them, and with what success. It also compares the leading products on the market across a number of headline criteria such as performance, scalability and vendor support.

Unfortunately, the free section doesn't give much. if you would like to read the whole 301 pages (301 pages?!?) you'll need to hand over 4995 USD (nearly Five thousand dollars).

Today I spoke with a customer and easily convinced them to use Reporting Services instead of Tablaue or QlikView. In some other scenarios I might recommend differently. Who's paying 5K for such document and far more interesting, who's reading 301 pages about the best BI tool?

 

Itay Braun

itay@twingo.co.il

www.twingo.co.il

תוכן התגובה

mikypuff כתב/ה:

Hi Itay,

First, this survey is not new at all. It was called the OLAP report before and they transformed it into the BI survey.

Second, I believe that a big company who's making its first steps in the "BI journey" can save a lot of money by consulting with a consultant or with this massive report.

# October 10, 2010 11:43 AM

Yvan כתב/ה:

I agree, the OLAP report is a good source of information, and it’s (at least officially) an independent company testing periodically the main BI tools. A company considering to start BI or replace old technologies SHOULD use the report, it will save money instead of getting consultancy from the main integrators and all of them are pushing one of the solution available in the market.

The problem is less which tool the customer is going to use, the main question should be, what exactly are you expecting from the solution (static reports, Analytic operations for power users, self-service ad hoc reporting and analysis, dashboards, Scorecard and so on). Many customers think that replacing the technology will solve their “real” problems, but the real life is more complex, solving business problems should be the first step when designing a new solution, then you can search an appropriate solution.

Now, many organization are looking for a solution but they do not want to code/customize anything (they say that the maintenance of such customization is expensive – well,  I quote “knowledge is expense? Try ignorance”, then check the bottom line , I think that a good BI solution must/have to include a certain level of customization because many scenarios are not really supported even with Microsoft….

The OLAP report is also good to get the market trend, see how many projects were completed and successful, why some of them are a total failure and many other parameters that should be considered when implementing a bi solution for the entire organization (versus a small deployment).

# November 17, 2010 7:15 AM
שלח תגובה

(שדה חובה)  

(שדה חובה)  

(אופציונלי)

(שדה חובה) 

Please add 3 and 5 and type the answer here:


Enter the numbers above: